Then came a lawsuit during the heat
of the Republican gubernatorial primary challenging whether Bates
met residency requirements because of his time in Washington,
D.C., as a lawyer and McConnell aide.
An Oldham County judge ruled
against Bates, and instead of appealing, the Harvard-educated
lawyer
dropped off the ticket with Ernie Fletcher -- who went on to
become Kentucky's first GOP governor in a
generation.
Seventeen months later, Bates
insists he doesn't dwell on the setback that denied him election
to Kentucky's No. 2 office, now occupied by Steve Pence,
Fletcher's choice as a replacement on the ticket.
"My view in life is that we should
always look forward, not back, and that we should count the gains
and not the losses," Bates said in a recent interview.
Bates, 36, has carved out a new
life since then. He works for a prestigious law firm in
Louisville. He formed his own consulting business, which
represents some of Kentucky's largest corporate interests. He and
his wife, Jennifer, are busy with their two children. Fletcher
appointed him to the board of regents at Eastern Kentucky
University, where Bates got his undergraduate degree.
And he's still involved in
politics. He's a delegate at this week's Republican National
Convention in New York. He is statewide grassroots chairman of the
Bush-Cheney campaign. And he stood in for Fletcher as a member of
the platform committee at the Republican convention.
Looking back on the court case that
cost him the lieutenant governorship, Bates said it was his
decision to quit the race.
"I believe that taking that issue
up on multiple appeals was not in the best interest of Ernie
Fletcher or in the best interest of Kentucky getting the right man
as governor," Bates said. "And that was the only consideration I
had."
Still, it was a time of anguish for
Bates, a Whitley County native who had been chief of staff and
campaign manager for McConnell. One Sunday morning, his pregnant
wife was served with a subpoena compelling her to testify at a
hearing on the lawsuit. Bates said it was "probably the only time
I got angry in the whole process."
Bates said writing the withdrawal
speech was "by far the most difficult professional decision I've
ever had to make.It was the right thing to do, but just because it
was right didn't make it easy," he said.
Reflecting on the legal fight,
Fletcher said recently he was willing to appeal because the matter
"was larger than just that race." He said the court ruling could
leave others who, like Bates, spent time outside Kentucky, in
limbo.
"At some point, I would hope that
we get some sort of declaratory judgment on the residential
requirements of a gubernatorial or lieutenant gubernatorial
candidate because I think the ruling was wrong," he said.
Bates said he holds no grudges
about the lawsuit, filed by a University of Louisville student but
joined
-- and largely taken over -- by Bob Heleringer, running mate of
Steve Nunn. They made up a rival slate in the 2003 Republican
gubernatorial primary.
As for his future, Bates said he's
"never had a political master plan," but he doesn't rule out
running for elective office again.Fletcher and McConnell both said
Bates' future is bright. Fletcher said he would support Bates if
he seeks office again.
"He realizes that you have to wait
for the right timing and the right opportunity, and he has the
patience to do that," Fletcher said.
McConnell said Bates will "be one
of the top leaders of that generation for our party in the future.
And I fully expect that we'll hear from him again."